Showing posts with label lessons. Show all posts
Showing posts with label lessons. Show all posts

Sunday, 14 July 2019

Meaningful Self Assessment in English


This blog is based on the session I delivered at the Team English National Conference 2019. The full set of slides and handout are available at the end of the blog.

This is specifically focused on how we support pupils self assessing extended reading and writing responses. 

Why is self assessment important?

Most teachers would recognise that it is important for pupils to be able to self assess their work; pupils need to be able to evaluate if their responses are successful independently, especially in a world of 100% exams. Self assessment is also important in regards of teacher workload. We cannot give meaningful feedback on every piece of work that a pupils produces. Time spent ‘marking’ everything is time which is then not available for thoughtful planning. Teachers’ time is not an infinite resource. Work-life balance is important and happy teachers are better teachers. Therefore, we need to ensure that pupils can meaningfully self assess their own work. Yet, this does not happen without careful thought and planning on our behalf.

Problems and pitfalls with self assessment

-Pupils don’t have the knowledge and skills to evaluate their own work effectively
-It is seen as less valuable than other forms of marking/ feedback
-It is rushed (usually at the end of the lesson)
-It is not carefully planned/ part of the curriculum/ SOW

Showing pupils the ‘why’



Often pupils don’t ‘buy into’ the concept of self assessment. It may be that pupils see the ‘what’ before the ‘why’. Simon Sinek in his TED Talk argues that in marketing, companies often fail by focusing on ‘what’ they do rather than ‘why’ they do it. He argues that customers buy into values and beliefs rather than the end product. Therefore it is important for companies to ensure that they are clear about the purpose of what they do. Is this true of teaching? With self assessment pupils are aware of the product- picking out targets or writing what they need to do to improve- but don’t necessarily engage with the purpose of this.

As teachers, I would argue that we need to be much better at articulating the purpose of self assessment- the ‘why’.

The self assessment culture in the classroom



Ultimately, the culture of a classroom drives the behaviour and behaviour produces results.
It is important to reflect on the culture of self assessment and consider whether this culture drives ineffectual behaviours and therefore produces ineffectual results.

We need to keep articulating the core purpose of self assessment for pupils:

‘You need to be able to take ownership of your learning so you can spot success independently.’

Self assessment is essentially metacognition

To undertake meaningful self assessment we need to show that it is a process that is intrinsically part of the whole process, not just something done at the end of a response.
Broken down, the process needed might look something like this.



A misconception may be that this kind of metacognition is something which is independent from the teacher, however, pupils are unlikely to have these metacognitive processes innately, rather these thought processes need to be articulated and modelled explicitly until they become behaviours.

How can we plan to support effective self assessment?

Take the following question based on an AQA Paper 1 Q2. It is important to think carefully about what we skills or knowledge pupils will need to demonstrate to craft a successful response.



As experts, we can assess a response and make an accurate judgement as to whether pupils have met these criteria. However, as a novice a pupil would struggle to do this. However, we can reword these concepts in a way that makes it much easier for a pupil to recognise success. It will never replace the value of your feedback, but if they are able to do this it will most likely enable them to produce a much better response than if they didn’t.
Therefore, for this question I might design my success criteria in this way:



With repeated modelling and practice, pupils will be able to use this to improve their answer.
The process I would follow in my lesson might look something like this:



Therefore, the process of self assessment should not be seen as merely a ‘plenary’, but an active part of the whole task.

Self assessing writing

I would argue that pupils find it more difficult to self assess their writing. Yet, being able to proof read and improve their writing is a hugely important skill. For writing I take a slightly different approach.

Here is an example of a self assessment criteria that I use for descriptive writing:



As with a reading response, I would model and annotate any of the features I expect the pupils to demonstrate on the board and pupils would copy this down as a model they can refer back to.

I would also give pupils much more time to self assess a piece of writing, ideally as a starter during the next lesson as having time away from their work helps build the critical distance necessary to assess their own work.

As pupils get more confident with this I allow pupils to create their own ‘success criteria’, or annotate their work with the technique they have used and the effect they were trying to create. This helps pupils see the connection between being a reader and a writer.

Here is an example of a piece of transactional writing completed by one of my Y9 pupils:














‘Top tips’ for effective self assessment

-Start small- get pupils to assess a few things well
-Keep the format the same to reduce cognitive load
-Allow enough time for the task to be done properly
-Model the process
-Allow for repeated practice
-Use metacognitive language- articulate your thought process when assessing work
-Be careful with your language- don’t just reward success, success is also being able to spot errors

But… we need to support an effective self assessment culture in school

-HODs and SLT need to be on board
-School leadership needs to value this as a form of feedback and support teachers
-Book scrutinies/ policy need to recognise this
-Teachers need to share what works well and be trained in what effective self assessment looks like
-Effective self assessment doesn’t happen on its own- it takes hard work but is valuable



An electronic copy of the slides and handout are available here. I am happy for you to share as long as I'm credited for the work: 

TENC2019 Self Assessment Resources

Sunday, 2 December 2018

Making the invisible visible: The problem with the one-off observation


‘People generally see what they look for and hear what they listen for’ To Kill a Mockingbird

Lesson observations are highly problematic; for the stress they induce in teachers and for the limited returns they provide in assessing the quality of teaching in schools. As an inexperienced teacher there have been times when I’ve spent hours over planning lesson plans for observations, trying to do something jazzy or spectacular or trying to prejudge what that particular observer will want to see. The resulting lessons may have ‘looked good’ within that hour snapshot or failed miserably because they were not reflective of my teaching. We also all know that teacher that can pull out the ‘outstanding observation lesson’ whilst their day to day practice is lack lustre. What does an observer really learn from such a process? Ultimately they have not learned the true picture of their staff and therefore the process fails to address what should be the real purpose of such an endeavour; to adequately access the strengths and weakness of a department so best practice can be shared and teaching and pupil outcomes can improve.

Furthermore, the problem with the hour lesson observation is that it is merely an arbitrary snapshot within a wide scheme of learning that has happened over the course of weeks, if not months. Whilst I’m sure some schools use this process as a genuine dialogue where the context of learning can be explained by the teacher being observed, my experience is any ‘dialogue’ afterwards does not go much further than the classic ‘so how do you think that went?’ where the answer does nothing to change the grade which has been already decided by the observer. This leads to the inevitable fear, distrust, frustration and anxiety that are all too often tied into the observation process. Thankfully, it seems that more and more schools are ditching grading and making the observation process more informal and reflective but much more needs to be done to get to a place where performance management is less about compliance and auditing and more about growth and improvement.
Learning is often invisible to the naked eye and individual lessons don’t necessarily give a true picture of the groundwork that has gone into what can be observed at that particular moment. This felt very apparent in lesson I taught last week…

I am a very boring teacher. I mean this in the sense that I have deliberately ditched a lot of the faddy ‘engaging’ activities that were the mainstay of my NQT years. This is mainly because I very much believe that if there are two ways to teach something, we should prioritise the one that is the most efficient. Routines are very important to me. I don’t mean in the sense of behaviour (but that is also true) but I try to keep lessons in the same format so that the learning is the focus, not the activity. Therefore, come into my lesson and you are likely to see the following:

  •         I begin with a starter that introduces a ‘big question’ or recap previous learning if appropriate
  •        I will then introduce the main task/ success criteria
  •        Then we will read the text together, pupils will then annotate it independently or in pairs
  •        We feedback and check for misconceptions
  •      I then model the beginning of the answer on the board (using questions to get input from the pupils) explaining how the answer is meeting the success criteria.
  •       They then work in silence for around 20mins
  •      We self assess using the success criteria (I model this by doing one under the visualiser)


A huge proportion of my lessons follow this same procedure. If you are an observer who doesn’t like teacher talk or wants to see group work- you are looking at an inadequate lesson. Yet, through my experience and research I believe this works- it’s the most efficient way for pupils to learn and allows time for deeper understanding of texts through the questioning I can lead and direct.

So, this week I thought I would try something different. Instead of modelling the answer on the board, I sat down at the back of the lesson and handed my pen to one of the pupils and said ‘I want you to be the teacher for this bit’. The pupil got up and went to the board and asked just the questions I would have asked, prompting the other pupils, taking different responses and then evaluating which was the best to one to then write on the board as part of the answer. Now, I sometimes had to nudge them in the right direction but they pretty much produced a brilliant model answer, using the exact process I would have. Sitting at the back of the classroom, I was struck how a casual observer to this lesson would see so many ‘outstanding’ things: pupils taking responsibility for their own learning, demonstrating metacognition, working together, evaluating ideas, being kind and supportive to each other’s opinions. Yet, this lesson would not have been possible a month ago, it is only because of all those lessons of that embedded those routines and explicit explanation of the mental process that this lesson was possible. In that lesson, the success of that much maligned ‘didactic’ teaching was invisible.

I use this anecdotal example as I think it neatly shows how one lesson can never fully show the snapshot of teaching or learning that is going on in a classroom. For an observer much of what is and has been happening (particularly if done well) is invisible, therefore it is vitally important for the ongoing improvement of teaching and learning within a school that teachers are empowered to be part of the observation dialogue, to be able to explain, contextualise and reflect during the observation process.

We need to be able to make the invisible visible.

Saturday, 20 October 2018

Me and Mrs Jones: What my teacher really taught me


How much do you remember about your English lessons when you were a pupil? The majority of my lessons I remember as a blur, an amalgamation of lessons over time. It’s strange the small details I do remember, the obscure quotations from texts such as the Merchant of Venice or Macbeth, the distinct feeling of hatred I felt towards Gerald in An Inspector Calls (and presumably because of this, I can remember clearly who read out his part in class). In amongst these recollections is the memory of my Standard Grade (Scottish equivalent of GCSE) teacher, Mrs Jones. I don’t think I would ever have called Mrs Jones my favourite teacher at the time, but now, as a teacher myself looking back, I see that Mrs Jones has shaped my teacher identity more than I perhaps consciously realise.

What Mrs Jones taught me about being a good English teacher 

Mrs Jones never gave the impression that she particularly liked us. There is no one that could give a pithy burn like Mrs Jones. She was quick, concise and devastating with her comments, in a moment she could cut down your 14 year old arrogance in a way that never felt personal or unjustified. This, I now know as a teacher myself is an important, implicit behaviour management technique, a way of putting pupils in their place with grace and humour but more importantly with the edge that lets the class know that they have met their match. Do I always emulate this? No… sadly not, I don’t think I could ever quite reach the Mrs Jones level. Yet, I do think this ‘English teacher wit’ is an important part of a good English teacher’s identity.

As a pupil I was not aware of the idea of someone having ‘high expectations of us’, yet, as a teacher looking back, Mrs Jones embodied this. To us, we always thought she was harsh. We felt she marked our work more harshly than other teachers. She wanted more of us when we gave a lazy answer. Now whilst these things did not make you a popular teacher, when I think about it, it made me work harder to gain her respect.

Who cares?

Now, despite giving the impression that she did not particularly like any of her pupils there are two instances that really stick out to me that shows that Mrs Jones cared a lot. When I was 14 my great grandmother died in very tragic circumstances; she suffered a heart attack after a local teenager threw a stone through the window of her retirement home. In a strange twist of fate, a few weeks after this, we were reading a short story where the events mirrored this in an uncanny way. After reading the story Mrs Jones pointed out a case in that happened locally which showed that this sort of thing happened in real life. I imagine the point she was trying to get across was that as teenagers, our actions have consequences, which is clearly an important message. Yet, for me this was not ‘a story’ in the local press, it was my great grandmother. It was the end of the lesson and I burst into (what I felt) were discrete tears. I don’t even remember telling my friends afterwards what was wrong (although I possibly did). I composed myself and went to my next lesson. Later that day I was in Graphic Communication and Mrs Jones came to the door and asked to speak to me. She had come to apologise for the lesson, she hadn’t been aware that the woman she was referring to was my great grandmother. I have no idea how she found this out but it made a world of difference to me that she came to find me to explain and check I was ok. That’s the thing about English, we deal with subjects have the ability to shock, to upset, to touch us in a powerful way and this always needs to be done with sensitivity… but it needs to be done. Despite my personal reaction and connection to those events, I believe that if the story and the connection she made between it and my great grandmother’s case touched someone else, made them think about their actions in future, it was all worth it.

The second thing is a small point but one I see in a different way now I’m a teacher myself. Now, perhaps I shouldn’t mention this given my job, but I have always struggled with spelling. Clearly Mrs Jones had picked up on the disparity between my general ability in English and my ability to spell. One day after lesson she held me back and gave me a pocket spell checker. Given what I know about teaching now, I imagine that spell checker was purchased with her own money and it is indicative of the kindness that the best teachers seem to have.

So despite the pithy putdowns and harsh marking, Mrs Jones clearly did care. She didn’t need to be our ‘friend’ or be soft on us, but she showed she cared when it mattered.

My best English lesson

At the start of this blog I mentioned how I could not remember discrete lessons, however that is not entirely true… I remember one lesson very vividly. It was the 12th of September 2001. I know the date because it was the day after the terrorist attack on the World Trade Centre. Sadly, we have become desensitised to terrorist attacks, for our pupils now terrorism is part of life, but the 9/11 attack was truly shocking and in hindsight seemed to change everything. I remember coming home from school on the day it happened and seeing my mum enraptured in front of the TV as I passed the patio doors to our family room. I remember watching the plane smash into the side of the building on the small TV screen and not quite realising what I was watching, whether it was real or not.
The next day in English we didn’t carry on the lesson from before. We did something different. Mrs Jones had photocopied an opinion piece from one of the newspapers. I remember it was a defiant open letter to the terrorists. Our task was to read through it and then use the lines from the article to create our own poem.

It was powerful.

It is the only English lesson I distinctly remember and the reason for this is that Mrs Jones recognised the significance of this event in history, its raw topicality, the need for us to process what had happened through language. Mrs Jones clearly recognised the need to sometimes take time out from the SOW, the mid term plan, the exam preparation and focus on what is important: The way in which language shapes our understanding of the world.

Mrs Jones taught me two important lessons that day, one as a child and one as an English teacher. She taught me the need for English to be reflexive to the world around us and to use English as a tool to understand and shape the word around us.

I said at the beginning of this blog that I would not have considered Mrs Jones my favourite teacher but in hindsight she was my best teacher and has shaped me as an English teacher more than she could have possibly imagined. It is with great regret that I didn’t say ‘thank you’ at the time and I hope that one day she might know the profound impact she has had on my teacher identity.